It's time to play over/under once again. It's simple I list two bands and for each band you say what you think is the most overrated song by that band and then their most underrated song. So the bands this time are:
Metallica
Megadeth
**So what do you think are the most overrated and underrated tracks by these artists?
Metallica Overrated: Anything after "...Justice..."
ReplyDeleteMetallica Underrated: Anything before "...Justice..." (except "Sanitarium")
Metallica, Over: The entire Justice album, Turn The Page
ReplyDeleteMetallica, Under: Stone Cold Crazy
Megadeth, Over: Peace Sells, But Who's Buying? (Song, not album)
Megadeth, Under: Lucretia
Metallica Over: Anything from Load
ReplyDeleteMatallica Under: Seek and Destroy
Megadeth: Over: Peace Sells
Megadeths Under: Symphony of Destruction...
But what do I know really?
Metallica: Over - The Unforgiven; Under - Seek & Destroy
ReplyDeleteMegadeth: Over - Peace Sells; Under - Symphony of Destruction
Metallica: over - Sad But True
ReplyDeleteunder - Fade to Black
Megadeth: over - Sweating Bullets
under - A Tout le Monde
Metallica
ReplyDeleteOver-pretty much the whole Justice album
Under-The Outlaw Torn-from Load...that song ROCKS, pretty much the ONLY thing on Load that does
Metallica
ReplyDeleteOver-Enter sandman
Under-Disposable heroes
Megadeth
Over-Symphany of destruction
Under-Hook in mouth
Also,
ReplyDeleteMetallica, Under: The black album (I should add the disclaimer that yes, I think Master of Puppets is superior and possibly even Ride The Lightning, but I don't think the black album is as bad as some fans think. It turned me on to the band in the first place).
Over: St. Anger- I've never heard of anyone liking the song, but just in case they do, then it's vastly overrated.
Metallica Over rated:
ReplyDeleteEverything after the Black album.
Ok maybe not ST.Anger. I think everyone agreed that was a stinky pile of cow dung.
Megadeth Under rated:
The System Has Failed, and probably a few others.
I must admit, I have become more of a Megadeth fan over the years, and less of a Metallica fan. Lars Ulrich and James Hetfield both need to shut up, and just create some quality new music.
Metallica-
ReplyDeleteOverrated: Unforgiven
Underrated: Disposable Heroes
Megadeth-
Overrated: Sweating Bullets (I hate the vocal on this song)
Underrated: Hook in Mouth
I think Metallica is overrated in general, but maybe I just have Lars issues.
ReplyDeleteMetallica
ReplyDelete--Overrated=Disposable Heroes
--Underrated=Blackened
Megadeth:
--Overrated=most, but I'll pick Peace Sells
--Underrated=I'll agree with Hook in Mouth
-- david
Metallica:
ReplyDeleteOverated Song:
Anything not 80's/early 90's
Underated Song:
Turn The Page
Megadeth:
Overated Song:
Sweating Bullets
Underated Song:
Hangar 18
Metallica:
ReplyDeleteOverated Song:
Anything not 80's/early 90's
Underated Song:
Turn The Page
Megadeth:
Overated Song:
Sweating Bullets
Underated Song:
Hangar 18
Metallica Overrated: King Nothing
ReplyDeleteMetallica Underrated: The Call of the Ktulu (While it may not be overlooked by Metallica fans it isn't too well known beyond Metallica fans)
I'm not a Megadeath fan so I can't comment.
Metallica
ReplyDeleteOver: Until it Sleeps
Under: Disposable Heroes
Megadeth
Over: Sweating Bullets
Under: Tornado of Souls
Overrated Metallica - Nothing Else Matters
ReplyDeleteUnderrated - Hit the Lights
Overrated Megadeth - Crush 'Em
(I have to disagree with the consensus of people picking "Peace Sells." It's still potent, still angry, still indicative of what good metal is, plus it proves that STILL nobody cares about peace)
Underrated - Hook in Mouth
BTW, I have the new Megadeth disc...overall good, though kinda derivative and he redoes "A Tout Le Monde" with backup singers...yipe...still, Mustaine can shred
Metallica
ReplyDeleteOver-rated Master Of Puppets
Under....Ride....'tallca's finest 45 minutes.
Metallica: over - post And Justice...
ReplyDeleteUnder : Fade To Black
Megadeth: Over - Nothing comes to mind
Under: Go To Hell
Interesting reponses on these two. I will another over/under next month.
ReplyDeleteMetallica, Over : Enter Sandman (of course over played)
ReplyDeleteMetallica, Underrated: Orion
Megadeth, Over: Hangar 18 (over played)
Megadeth, Under: Mary Jane
Overrated:
ReplyDeleteMetallica: Thing that should Not Be
Megadeth: Devil's Island
Underrated:
Metallica: Dyer's Eve or Escape
Megadeth: Liar